Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC




About LS.n

Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC
by Chris Tyrrell

published 2/22/99

FEATURES HOME

Chris Tyrrell is LeisureSuit.net's Staff Humorist.

MOST RECENT YAK ABOUT THIS ARTICLE:

Subj: XTC
I saw XTC and The Police in Detroit back in the 80's at Cluth Cargo's and was blown away... Colin and Andy should come back to Detroit to record and get that soul feeling that's aching inside them. C'mon boys, we're waiting.
-- Rick
Mar 8, 2006 at 9:20PM
Read more or post your own

It's GOOD to share!
E-mail this article to a buddy

XTC

Andy Partridge and Colin Moulding

They'd tour, but the lead singer's afraid. They'd make videos, but past efforts have been just awful. They'd live the rock and roll life, but they're broke. They'd release an album, but their record company was too busy designing new forms of cola. They'd be popular, but their instincts are far from commerciality. Plus, they've lost three band members and the sense of hearing (perhaps it was working overtime) in the past three decades. This is Pop? This is pathetic.

Were it not for the fact that XTC is beloved, in the strongest sense of the word, by those that . . . belove them, they would just be "those guys that did the 'Dear God' song." But the XTC melodrama has been wonderfully, tragically played out for those of us that worship at the altar of all things Partridge & Moulding (and of course, Gregory, Chambers, and Andrews). Is the time now right for their big breakthrough? In the words of Theodoric of York, "Nah."

Andy Partridge and Colin Moulding are XTC, and always have been. They're releasing an album, the first in seven years, called "Apple Venus". And how's this for a hard sell? Moulding warns potential buyers that they'll have to listen to the album many times before they like it. "Most people listen to it and say, 'Christ . . . This is different!'" Different! That'll pack 'em into Tower. Then again, Moulding's first reaction to "Skylarking", their American 'breakthrough album' was, "Oh my God!" (and not in a good, orgasmic kind of way).

To really understand and appreciate XTC, one needs to be aware of their whole history, via books like Chalkhills and Children and XTC: Song Stories, or through the many Web sites devoted to them, such as www.chalkhills.org.

In short, XTC was punk in '77 with Andy, Colin, Barry Andrews (keyboard), and Terry Chambers (drums). Barry left. Dave Gregory came in on guitar. The quartet released critically acclaimed pop/rock albums, that mostly fell beneath the radar, save the devoted international fan base. They toured relentlessly. Andy got severe stagefright, so they ceased touring in the early '80s. Terry left. America liked "Dear God", but right-wingers tried to bomb radio stations. They were screwed for years by Virgin. They released nothing new for the last seven years. Andy lost his hearing, then got it back. Two new albums hit stores this year, courtesy of TVT Records. Oh, and now Dave's gone.

On the brighter side--and there is one--XTC has fought tooth and nail to be unique, to be themselves (whatever incarnation that is at the time), to be weird and witty, subtle and subversive, and always harmonious and melodious, even amid chords that just don't sound right. Hence the lack of singles; hence the "love it or hate it" reaction to their music. And Moulding promises more of the same for the future, though he does see a new maturity in their work. "I think this is our most adult recording." Adult recording? Knowing XTC, this sounds naughty. "No," assures Moulding, "this isn't XXXTC."

"Apple Venus" represents the better tracks written over XTC's seven-year hiatus/standoff with Virgin Records. The near decade has seen old tracks packaged and repackaged, culminating in the four-disc set "Transistor Blast", which was lovingly chucked under the Christmas tree two months ago. But fans have been salivating for the new stuff, and 1999 promises to satiate their needs with the release of "Apple Venus" volumes I and II.

The first, hitting stores on Tuesday, February 23, contains songs of a "non-electrical" flavor, according to Moulding, while the electric volume will arrive later this year. A brilliant strategy? You would think. But Colin attributes the dual disc plan to not having enough budget to record all twenty-one songs at once. In fact, many of the tracks for "Apple Venus" had to be finished in his Swindon home. Music on a Farmboy's Wages.

The songs Andy Partridge has written for "Apple Venus" (the first)--such as "Knights in Shining Karma", "Easter Theatre", "Your Dictionary", "The Last Balloon", and "Green Man"--lie in the familiar territories of stories about lovers' bliss/strife, the future of civilization, the spiritual and scientific worlds, and a wee bit of British history. Of course, it's the irony, the cheekiness, or the complexity of tone that make each song truly XTC's, whatever the topic.

XTC

Colin Moulding

Moulding has contributed two original songs to the mix: "Fruit Nut", which "is really just a novelty song dealing with English eccentrics and hobbyists," and "Frivolous Tonight", which the always modest Colin calls his best song ever. "It's really just about a night in. It's a light song. But I feel there's a shortage of light songs-- though I know how you Americans like your angsty songs. I don't know anything about the world really. This is a broad subject, just about having fun at home."

Indeed, XTC has grown up; the days of "Life Begins at the Hop" and "Radios in Motion" are gone, replaced by the ever-refined gems in their musical pantheon. Time off the road, since Andy's much-publicized (by XTC standards) retreat from the limelight, has made them into the tightest recording studio band possible. But could they have been more if Andy's fears hadn't surfaced?

"My reaction at the time," says Moulding, "was, 'My God, what are we going to do?' If you were in a band, you toured. But I think it strengthened us in other ways." Yes, but could they play live now? Moulding doesn't think it's such a hot idea. "It be just like going back to our short trousers. Touring has more of an affinity with aerobics than music. Besides, that decision was taken out of my hands a long time ago."

Resentment? Not on Colin's part. But Dave Gregory is another story. He joined the band after XTC's first two albums, "White Music", and "Go 2", and was the revered guitarist who for almost twenty years really was the other wheel on the tricycle. So why the sudden departure, now that XTC is back in business? "Dave was not a happy man." It seems Gregory had a history of fighting with the always outspoken Partridge about his limited role in the band. "And Dave loves playing guitar. With where we were going on 'Apple Venus', making so many songs acoustic, he became the reluctant keyboard player." Though he is on the new album, Gregory is very much out of XTC.

XTC

Andy Partridge

Andy Partridge, the suffering genius, the enigmatic frontman, has rattled enough bones over the course of XTC's history to cause many to abandon the ship. But Colin and Andy--the heart and soul of the band--have only had one falling out in their long history. This doesn't mean it's an egalitarian relationship, as songs written by Andy always outnumber those written by Colin on a given album.

"Andy can be a bit of a bully," says the more laid-back Moulding, "but everyone chips in. And I know I contribute a lot more to Andy's songs than he does to mine. I have principality in the XTC country. I haven't heard the tanks rumbling yet. And it's not time for exile."

Partridge and Moulding can afford to be in good spirits now, as they are rid of "a manager who was absolutely useless." In addition to the albums, there is an upcoming Bravo special featuring the band, and they are making a number of stops in America to tout their rebirth. And what of a bubblegum pop project that XTC had cooked up over the hiatus, in the same vein as their pseudonymous band, The Dukes of Stratosphear?

"Christ!" says Moulding, "I think that was the last straw with Virgin." He believes their "little twee vignette," all in the name of fun for the Swindon boys, was an idea that illustrated how Virgin and XTC had not been on the same page. Rabid fans will, for now at least, have to settle for XTC's psychedelic alter egos, the Dukes.

The Dukes of Stratosphear song "25 O'Clock," was resurrected on "A Testimonial Dinner," the XTC tribute album, by quirky comrades They Might Be Giants. TMBG continued the praise on their album "Factory Showroom", with the tune "XTC vs. Adam Ant". Colin Moulding can't be sure who would win that war. "We've been on the same battlefield. Although, he's an actor now, isn't he? Then I guess we're on different battlefields."

And now XTC is entering a new phase of adulthood. The four snotty punks have been whittled down to two pros, at the top of their game. They're beyond making plans (for Nigel), past their stint as mayor of Simpleton, and are, all of a sudden, ready to re-introduce themselves to a limited, but ecstatic audience. The rest of the world, as always, has a chance to catch up.

Name: Rick
Subject: XTC
-- Mar 8, 2006 at 9:20PM
I saw XTC and The Police in Detroit back in the 80's at Cluth Cargo's and was blown away... Colin and Andy should come back to Detroit to record and get that soul feeling that's aching inside them. C'mon boys, we're waiting.

Name: Rose
Subject: XTC
-- Mar 9, 2005 at 8:29PM
Wow. XTC is an absolutely amazing band. My friend introduced me to them just last year and since then, I've been completely hooked. I've listened to the albums Homegrown, The Big Express, Drums and Wires, Skylarking, Oranges and Lemons, and Apple Venus Vol. 2, and I must say Homegrown is my favorite. Even though most people says its one of their weaker ones, there is something about the simplicity that just draws me into it. My absolute favorite song by them would be Were All Light, along with Generals and Majors, Standing in For Joe, You and the Clouds Will Still be Beautiful, Dear God, Making Plans for Nigel, Science Friction, All You Pretty Girls, Seaguls Screaming Kiss Her, In Another Life, Love on a Farmboys Wages, The Loving, and The Mayor of Simpleton. They are truly a talented band, and I hope to acquire more of their cds very soon!

Name: hippieman
Subject: XTC
-- Jun 26, 2004 at 1:37AM
Make a CD that is cool.

Name: wxyzca2000
Subject: XTC
-- Mar 23, 2004 at 11:53PM
Go to Vancouver and cut an album.Good puffs and new high tech studio at chartsmusic studios.Chad and Art are cool dudes too bros.

Name: mohamed
Subject: Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC
-- Mar 2, 2004 at 3:44AM
jag vill ha xtc nu hache

Name: curious -Q
Subject: muice
-- Nov 14, 2003 at 10:42AM
I think i will go to consert to night mabay i wil go in the mash pit
sumbel around a bit go croud surf got to go my
teacher is theting to send me to the SRC room
a place were bad kid go
By got to go
curious-Q

Name: Maarten Kneppers
Subject: XTC definetely rules!
-- Oct 24, 2003 at 11:00AM
Hai Allen,

I am a big XTC fan myself. Everyone of their albums has AT LEAST 50% very great songs on it. But the (in my opinion)truly great are: Black Sea, Drums & Wires, English Settlement, Skylarking (THE best!), Oranges & Lemons, Nonsuch, Apple Venus Vol. 1. These albums will really blast you away! (if you don�t have them yet of course!).
By the way on the KAZAA network there is a video circulating from XTC called "Dear God" (from the Skylarking US album). A great song and a fine video!
Enjoy Allen, let me know your findings!!

GReetings Maarten (the netherlands)

Name: Allen Valencia
Subject: XTC rules
-- Oct 24, 2003 at 12:50AM
I have actually 3 albums of XTC, the Black Sea, Oranges and Lemons and the one which includes the song "Wake Up" (sorry if I forgot the album title). I learned to admire and idolize this band since 1980 after their release of the Black Sea album. Making Plans for Nigel, Respectable Street, Love at First Sight, Wake Up, Hold me my Daddy, King for a Day and Burning with Optimism's Flame are my own personal favorites. I find their music melodious, catchy and amusing. Although I watch MTV that often, I never had a chance to see even one of their music videos! I just wanna know from you XTC fans out there what's the best album they have ever released. I'm from Manila and I would await your opinions on this. Is the English Settlement or Fossil Fuel albums satisfied your tastes? Hope to hear from you soon. Thanks.

Name: Robert B
Subject: XTC
-- Oct 18, 2003 at 10:37PM
Have loved them since 1981 through all the changes. Great songs, and great, weird arrangements. Uniquely BRITISH.

Name: Sparky Doolittle
Subject: Lets hope the DVD Happens
-- Sep 24, 2003 at 7:09AM
Here's to hoping that the
legal stuff thats holding up the Planned DVD gets worked out.
Surely and awsome product when or if it happens.
Sparky

Name: Alan H
Subject: XTC live
-- Jun 20, 2003 at 8:52AM
I saw XTC live at the Lyceum in London and at Brighton Top Rank in the early 80's. I too sang along and had lost my voice the next day. I had tickets to see them at the Hammersmith Palias (I think) but when I got there the gig was cancelled due to Andy's 'stomach problem'.

They were great live - they are great on record. The main thing for me about XTC (also suggested in the sleeve notes of 'Coat of Many Cupboards') in that you can listen to their songs 100 times and get something out of it each time. When you've listened to an XTC song once you can't guarantee you've 'got' it. I know that's true of many acts but it's also not true of many others.
By the way, I don't agree that 'Boat' was no good - it was one of my favourites for ages. If you've learnt to play it on guitar maybe you'll know what I mean.

Name: Mr. Portland
Subject: tedheshi
-- Jan 1, 2003 at 7:28PM
Mr. Tedheshi,

It's all in the fingers.

Some people are born with that true spark of originality, while others prefer to make their living ripping off others. If you're a member of the first group, you can make a hit record with whatever's available. If you belong to the second group, you probably have a bright future in real estate or the legal profession.

I've heard your stuff. You could try another amplifier, but I think you might want to consider changing your approach entirely.

Mr. Portland

Q: What do you call a musician with no girlfriend?
A: Homeless.

Name: swindonboy
Subject: teamwork
-- Dec 30, 2002 at 12:11PM
Andy & Co.
Stop acting like important tarts and give us what we need!!

you know who:-)

Name: Daveyjoe
Subject: XTC
-- Dec 11, 2002 at 3:57AM
I love the boys, in spite of Andy's naive politics--naive worldview in general. 'Cause it's all about the music, and XTC makes some of the best pop music going. I miss Dave Gregory; every band needs a great instrumentalist who doesn't write. XTC isn't really a band any more, just like Steely Dan (more brilliant pop music of a very different kind) haven't been a band for a long time. Just a couple of songwriters. Ah, well, so long as they keep working.

Name: naida
Subject: the xtc
-- Nov 27, 2002 at 5:04AM
i know that you cant give
any e-mails.I am an artist and would like
to send some of my simple
pictures for xtc-andy or
colin...
could you send on these cards for them some how please(if you have the time)
naida

Name: ronnaz
Subject: on the house
-- Nov 26, 2002 at 10:46AM
space Once upon a time some(+)people did art for nothing(40)...for l0VE.Birds fantailed landings...eXcellent eye opener.Nothing is clearer than a perfect fishlens...and UNravelling the net...10 points for that shot.I`m not great at this web stuff, but I`ll try to do some low flying. I have XO(NetZero),10 hrs a month. Over And Out

Name: naida
Subject: the interview
-- Nov 15, 2002 at 3:11AM
thank you for good interview .Theyalways do what is right in teir own
sight.Id like to know
about xtc video concrete things,but i know-they have never had enough money for that thing
naida

Name: Andy
Subject: The XTC Thing
-- Nov 14, 2002 at 9:09AM
How big could this band have been if only Andy Partridge had not been such a dick. Not only did he fail to build up any sort of fanbase by not touring (much) and releasing junk like 'Wait til your boat goes down', he slagged off God at every turn. If only they had recorded 'Jesus he knows me', they would have been massive. Still, overall, what a brilliant legacy they left (are leaving ?) as heard on 'Fossil Fuel'...apart from mush like 'Wonderland'. Shame.

Name: naida
Subject: making plans for nigel
-- Nov 2, 2002 at 3:58AM
i have ,the best punk,, video,, it is very interesting video i like the xts the stranglers the sex pistols...i would have more

Name: andoidonnan
Subject: xtc
-- Oct 14, 2002 at 7:51AM
To rate albums in order of preference is largly a worthless exercise. Each installment represents a period of work within which the thoughts and ideas of xtc are expressed to the best of their ability. As the whole process of critisism is a subjective one , the only peopole who can really define what is being said are the artists themselves, once the album goes public it can only be defined relative to sucess as the band themselves see it. As for myself as long as xtc buck the trend of manufactured pop based upon a pick and mix marketing strategy, the best of luck to them. All their albums contain melodies and music i enjoy and occassionaly some i didn't, but as it wasn't written for me in the first place why be critical. Keep it up xtc.

Name: Ernesto
Subject: xtc
-- Jul 27, 2002 at 9:06AM
xtc, es solo xtc !son excelentes!

Name: stevie.G
Subject: Xtc
-- Jul 24, 2002 at 9:13PM
I fell for xtc after seeing them on and I might be mistaken about this sight and sound in concert on BBC2 live on the tv and also through stereo radio.This was back in about 78/79 .If I am mistaken it must have been rock goes to college .Can anyone remember this ? Me and my freinds were blowin away by this but it was the one and only time we have ever seen them live. I wonder if the BBC ever kept any of these gigs on film????

Name: stan
Subject: xtc chords
-- Jul 3, 2002 at 12:10PM
some of the chords used are the dog's bollocks

Name: grant
Subject: terry
-- Jun 25, 2002 at 11:20PM
terry chambers is one of my favourite drummers and xtc records were what i used to learn how to play. i even got tama and paiste gear just like terry. i never knew that one day i would become a professional muso and travel around the world in a band , then spit the dummy like he did and walk out. sad isn't it. my band was no xtc thats for sure. xtc is still the best.xtcrnrg

Name: Glyn
Subject: XTC
-- Apr 19, 2002 at 7:03AM
Why is Nonsuch so disliked. listen to it. Wrapped in Grey is Andy's favourite song and Rook is a song that most songwriters would give their right hand to have written. Dear Madam Barnum is another Mayor of simpleton. And the guitar playing at the end of Books are Burning is among the best you'll ever hear. The album points very clearly towards AV1 and every song contains enough ideas for an oasis album. It just doesn't fit the "Pop" pigeonhole but the songs are little works of great beauty.
I used to be a Costello fan but after hearing his latest effort i remain disappointed.

Name: Alan R
Subject: XTC Live
-- Apr 16, 2002 at 10:30AM
I know that you that I know that XTC no longer perform live - poor old Andy P - but I have to say that I am one of the lucky ones that saw them play live TWICE on the road promoting Black Sea - I still tink that live performance of Scissor Man was the greatest

Name: JACKIE LAWRENCE
Subject: XTC
-- Mar 26, 2002 at 9:43AM
NICE

Name: Paulie
Subject: Wasp Star
-- Feb 8, 2002 at 1:47PM
I was sad when I saw Dave Gregory wasn't on Wasp Star. So why is this the best album XTC has ever put together? Maybe because I can't figure it out.

Name: Wanda(holland-Italy)
Subject: allways XTC
-- Jan 17, 2002 at 5:59PM
My yacht will be dance forever if I had a son I would call him Nigel.I was so glad to see the apple venus cd after all that time.The show I have seen of XTC was at Amsterdam I was at the first line singing every word(about 20 years ago).Anyway you can wake me up at any time for listening their songs.Let them Play forever.

Name: PHIL (France)
Subject: NO subject
-- Dec 27, 2001 at 7:26AM
I WAS JUST SURFING ON THE WEB AND I felt on my favorite band's site .I'm waiting for the new album of the best band in the world!!!

Name: joel
Subject: the big picture
-- Dec 22, 2001 at 9:16PM
~been in love with the band since hearing generals and majors on american bandstand...if you can belive that.try turning off the lights...putting on some quality headphones and plug in river of orchids....its like watching a painting come to life.

Name: Petter
Subject: songs
-- Dec 1, 2001 at 9:37AM
Wlcome to the garden of earthly delights aso
I am just stunned...

Name: SHIMI
Subject: XTC
-- Nov 24, 2001 at 10:36AM
XTC music will live on
because of well crafted
lyrics and catchy guitar
hooks, I am pretty partial to Black Sea and
English settlement

SHIMI

Name: Paul Martin
Subject: Ce groupe XTC
-- Nov 16, 2001 at 8:32PM
Juste pour dire que franchement dans le genre Pop, le groupe XTC est le plus r�jouissant que je puisse entendre depuis 20 ans (d�j� !). CONTINUEZ !!!!

Name: Paul Martin
Subject: Ce groupe XTC
-- Nov 16, 2001 at 8:30PM
Juste pour dire que franchement dans le genre Pop, le groupe XTC est le plus r�jouissant que je puisse entendre depuis 20 ans (d�j� !). CONTINUEZ !!!!

Name: Mike
Subject: It's so unfair!
-- Nov 14, 2001 at 6:20PM
Why did they have to exist? This band is exactly what the drug of the same name does. It's the aural equivalent! Like the drug, I feel this band should be made illegal! No one should be allowed to feel this good about music. NO ONE!

Name: matthew
Subject: apple venus vol 2
-- Oct 16, 2001 at 3:04PM
I JUST STARTED LISTENING TO THEM WHEN I HEARD "KING FOR A DAY" FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE I WAS A KID WHILE LIVING IN YUMA AZ ON A STATION OUT OF BAJA (SPANISH STATION I.D AND NO COMMERCIALS IT WAS GREAT AND ALL "ALT" AND 80'S THAT'S ANOTHER STORY) BUT I BOUGHT UPSY DAISY ASSORTMENT AND HAVE BEEN HOOKED EVER SINCE BUT I HAVE YET TO HEAR HEAR VOL 2 WHAT IS IT LIKE OR IS IT LIKE SEX YOU CAN SAY HOW WONDERFUL IT IS BUT UNTIL YOU DO IT YOU WON'T REALLY UNDERSTAND? SOMETHING LIKE THAT? MAIL ME BACK.

Name: earl
Subject: xtc
-- Sep 28, 2001 at 2:11PM
two words sum them up
THE BEST liked them since english settlement apple venus vol. 1&2 outstanding thanks

Name: earl
Subject: xtc
-- Sep 28, 2001 at 2:10PM
two words sum them up
THE BEST liked them since english settlement apple venus vol. 1&2 outstanding thanks

Name: Harald
Subject: XTC
-- Sep 27, 2001 at 2:57AM
I startet listening XTC
in 1986 when I heard "That's Really Super..." on air. After these 15 years I can say , XTC music has changed my life and my living here on this human earth.

Name: AUSSIE
Subject: VIDEO CLIPS
-- Jun 4, 2001 at 7:15AM
THIS IS ALL A LOT OF BITCHIE CRAP I DONT REALLY CARE ABOUT, SORRY. I`M JUST AFTER ANY VIDEO CLIPS THAT MIGHT BE AVAILABLE.

Name: eric lundgren
Subject: hey colin
-- Apr 22, 2001 at 3:35PM
i would love to get this message to colin moulding!!!!!!
hello colin,i am a big xtc fan from the get go...
i saw the show you did backing up the police in vancouver circa early 80's
somehow i got to the floor and right to the front of the stage
you and i communicated throughout the show
commenting to one another whether or not we liked the song that you were playing...
at the end of the [incredible] show a roady
came up to me and asked me if i was so and so [cant remember] i being an honest young canadian boy said 'no...yes'...
the raody was gone in an instant and my future was somehow changed
im not some crazy fan or anything,,,but at the time was hoping to get into music...at 18 or 19 i had incredible chops and sometimes i wonder what may have happened that fatefull day 20 years past...this wow internet place just might yield some answers...if you do end up reading this you can email me at ericandrewlundgren@h ome.com
by the way ive loved your music and even did apub crawl throughout the swindon area[1989]hoping to buy you guys a pint or 10...
peace to you and yours...Eric the half abee went to have a pee pulled it out and found a trout!!!!!

Name: evan
Subject: palladium show
-- Mar 19, 2001 at 7:24PM
hey gigi, i was at that show too! i still cry when i think about it. it is kinda cool, though, to say, 'i was at the last show xtc never played!'

Name: Steve
Subject: XTC in the Supermarket
-- Mar 18, 2001 at 1:40PM
I was in a foul mood from a crappy day at work when I realized I needed to stop and get food for the night. I grabbed the little green basket, walked through he automatic doors where I picked up the almost overwhelmed muzak from the overhead speakers. It was "King for a Day"! Somebody turned it into muzak! It was so perfect I laughed out loud!

Name: eddy
Subject: xtc still in my head
-- Mar 18, 2001 at 12:20AM
I cleaned out my house the other day,no room for junk or old memories.I took over 1000 LP's to a trade it CD store for $60.00 credit on new music.Of course the only LP's I keeped were my XTC LP's.I have a CD player for my new xtc CD's.All I need now is a LP turn table.

PS my kids love that XTC X-mas song I play every December.

Name: Steg
Subject: White Music
-- Feb 25, 2001 at 8:45AM
Can anyone help me. I have recently gotten hold of a copy of XTC's CD White Music but with no front or
back cover. If anyone out there could send me a copy or give me an address to
download it I would be most grateful. Would also like to say that the album itself is one of the best to
emerge from the punk era.
contact:steg.mc@ btinternet.com
Cheers
Steg

Name: Gwen
Subject: Wonderful!
-- Feb 24, 2001 at 10:33PM
XTC is a wonderful band.I love getting to know there music!I can't wait til they release more albums.I have been scowing albelta for their "dukes" albums.And some posters with no avail...Oh well I guess I will just have to live with what I got already.

Name: gigi
Subject: love that xtc!
-- Feb 10, 2001 at 3:47AM
It all began @ a 10 watt college radio station @ Washington University St. Louis. Life began @ the hop & I was the DJ. I also Love "Black Sea". I was @ The Palladium in Los Angeles when the show was abrubtly canceled. It was a Sunday night in 1982. So close, yet so very far. I was so sad. There is some footage of XTC performing live in the punk film "urrrrgh, a musical war". when "english settlement" was released in England it was a double album hope it is availiable as a cd. More XTC love later.

Name: gigi
Subject: love that xtc!
-- Feb 10, 2001 at 3:45AM
It all began @ a 10 watt college radio station @ Washington University St. Louis. Life began @ the hop & I was the DJ. I also Love "Black Sea". I was @ The Palladium in Los Angeles when the show was abrubtly canceled. It was a Sunday night in 1982. So close, yet so very far. I was so sad. There is some footage of XTC performing live in the punk film "urrrrgh, a musical war". when "english settlement" was released in England it was a double album hope it is availiable as a cd. More XTC love later.

Name: matt
Subject: andy
-- Feb 7, 2001 at 3:45PM
get mean

Name: Tomm
Subject: Hello!
-- Jan 14, 2001 at 10:55AM
Here I am in desolate upstate New York. On the cue is "Melt The Guns". Opened windows give way to the decibals. Deer dancing in the withered garden, blessed.
Here I am in a crowded mallway. Hurried are the ants of consumption. On my blaster throes "The Last Balloon". Hesitants stop to sneer, blessed.
Here I am in my DJ booth. Playlists preach the saviors of my job. In defiance plays "I'm the Man Who Murdered Love". Through the door I am ejected, blessed.

Name: Phil Richardson
Subject: I love XTC
-- Jan 7, 2001 at 10:33PM
When I first heard greenman on the radio I became hooked and went out and bought Apple Venus 1 and are trying to find the 2nd release. I was also wondering if any one else my own age (16) like their music... If so give us a yell (or mail).
flipthedrip@hotmail.com

Name: David Tedeschi
Subject: drums and wires
-- Dec 29, 2000 at 11:52AM
Howdy to all xtatic folks in England and beyond. I grew up in rural Missouri listening to xtc and it has shaped my view on music. I've often had robin hood like urges to steal from all of the hair bands of the eighties and give to the poor geniuses in xtc.
I'm a singer and songwriter with a studio and am interested in knowing what guitars and amps Dave and Andy used in the Drums and Wires/Black Sea period. Good raw unaffected tones, but what the hell are they using? Burning with Optimism's Flames is the most clever pop song I've ever heard. DT tedheshi@hotmail.com

Name: Randall Cobb
Subject: XTC Rules
-- Dec 21, 2000 at 1:32PM
Great Lyrics, catchy tunes. Their music is timeless. "Dear God" please tour!!

Name: Joe Chromy
Subject: Thank You
-- Dec 9, 2000 at 10:53PM
Good evening all! I am happy to say that English Settlement was the one album that opened up my universe to the melodic and inovative song writing and performances of XTC. I feel very, very fortunate to have loved and appreciated this band for over 17 years. Each time I come across someone that truly appreciates this band I feel like I am not alone in the world. This brotherhood of loyalists, either you love 'em or Hate 'em, all say one thing to me... Their music is timeless. Their writing is prolific, their orchestration is innovative. Immediately, I have a solid bond with these "siblings" of the XTC family. Each album / CD brings about a new world of experiences and emotion that makes me a better person through music appreciation. Thank you XTC for years of anticipation and wonderful memories. My greatest thrill is introducing new people to our flock!

Name: Marcos Marafioti
Subject: the best!!!!!!!!!!!
-- Dec 9, 2000 at 10:15PM
I really apreciate and enjoy XTC,thanks for the
unforgetable moments and plesure that given to me

Name: Andy Munro
Subject: XTC FOR SALE!
-- Nov 12, 2000 at 5:24PM
You can now check out my XTC List at my new website; http://home.beseen.com/homebiz/munrec

Name: JEFFREY RENION
Subject: hi.......
-- Oct 11, 2000 at 8:01AM
i want to look the picture of the volcano
and thier parts

Name: graeme
Subject: robbery
-- Oct 10, 2000 at 3:42PM
lost everything except Nonsuch, big Express, Black Sea, and Homespun, anyone with unplayed copies please: 30 Aviary View, Armley, Leeds. Not greedy, with return duplicates. Bless you, bless you...

Name: Bill Thon
Subject: XTC
-- Oct 4, 2000 at 6:38PM
I have all the C's and buy people copies
to get them all started - I have made XTC
fans out of all of them.
I saw them in Cleveland Ohio in the 80's.
I will never forget it. TellAndy and Colin i love them,
We all love them here in Los Angeles.
No one is like them or ever will be.
I hope they Put out a DVD in AC3 - Don;t even worry about video quality.
We just want to see you singing.
Bill

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: On US Telvision? When?!?
-- Sep 28, 2000 at 6:19AM
Michael,

That's a good question. I haven't heard anything about it since Colin mentioned it. You might want to check out the Chalkhills web site for info., or even Bravo's web site. And if you get a date, please let me know!

Name: Michael DuVall
Subject: On US Telvision? When?!?
-- Sep 27, 2000 at 5:59PM
I saw in the interview that there was going
to be a "speacial" on the Cable channel 'Bravo'.

Is this true? When is it (was it) on? I need to see it!

Thanks a million times over...

Name: STEWART
Subject: XTC
-- Sep 11, 2000 at 3:09PM
-been listening to XTC since '82, and they remain my favorite. Can anyone help me get the live radio sessions in the US? I have some, but am missing others such as Blue Beret. THANKS.. knoeppsm@musc.edu

Name: ALAN-NJ
Subject: TO JIM &ALL FANS
-- Aug 28, 2000 at 4:10PM
First off, i understand the exuberance and frustration you and others try to relate in your writtings about XTC.
It is nearly impossible to comprehend why thier brilliance and importance is not more widely recognized.
We,as rabid fans, must take comfort in the fact that we are a brighter bunch, exampled by our ability to "get" thier music.

Thier genious is further proven by the latest masterwork "WASP STAR".
It showcases thier ability to mature and expand on what i thaught was impossible to improve on. It is thier best work to date! (but then again i think that of each new album),which in my mind is further proof of greatness. Also, they are the only band that can do that.

Right now i'm listening to "selling england by the pound" (genesis) who were to me one of the very few bands before XTC that were able to achieve such consistent excellence. they were the most literate,intelligent and musically interesting band of thier time. just listen to "cinema show","supper's ready", firth of fifth","the lamb","dance on a volcano",robbery assault and battery","los endos","one for the vine","eleventh earl of mar"and "a trick of the tail" for proof.

OK, enough of genesis, this is an XTC rant!
talk about hardly mentioned songs,what about "chaulkhills",pink thing","poor skeleton","scarecrow people",humble daisy","then she appeared","the loving","books are burning","supergirl","earn enough for us",the meeting place","season cycle"/1000 umbrellas","big day","down in the cockpit","leisure",melt the guns","knuckle down" "yacht dance","great fire","love on a farmboy's wages","desert island","ladybird","easter theater","harvest festival","i can't own her","you and the clouds..","church of woman","playground","we're all light","my brown guitar","the wheel and maypole",etc.,etc,XTC.
In other words, almost everything they've done.
they're all my favorites.

How many bands have written over 100 songs that are truly inspiring?

NONESUCH!

Name: carl
Subject: the greatest band on earth
-- Aug 21, 2000 at 7:09PM
want to say that while I thouroughly enjoy apple venus vol. 2 I think I actually prefer vol. 1. anyway you look at it, xtc is by far the greatest band on earth.

Name: Jim Forsythe
Subject: i listen- i marvel
-- Aug 12, 2000 at 1:19PM
yes!

XTC is everything that "pop" music should be in a real world where people have an open mind to possiblities. I'm not afraid of the sappy pop sounds the boys can make because they do it with such style, grace, and imagination.

I'm not afraid of the "stuppid" Richards riff <to those who would cutdown this song for it's simplicity>
nor that Maypole is 2 songs-2 totally different thoughts<to those who can't handle the complexity>
crammed into one. It makes me want to press repeat on the CD player as soon as it's over.

Every cd i own Nonsuch, Oranges & Lemons, AV1, Dukes of Stratosphere-ChipsAnthology,Skylarking, WaspStar, Mummer, and Big Express (bought in that order)(would have'em all but money is an issue)
has brought me hours upon hours of musical entertainment, enjoyment, encouragment and discouragement (why can't i be that great?).

In them is that:
British thing (this texan loves), the sappy pop thang, the punk thing, the symphonic, the 80s, reggae, Elvis C, the trip/space sound, the jazz thing, the brillant mixing, use of non-cool instruments-made cool, the quirky voices, the beautiful voices and harmonies that a director of a symphony might die to fabricate, the twist of words that a poet might be proud to have weaved.

I'm with Dj. Could be rated in a fanatic category.
I do listen to other music ocassionally. Miles Davis,
Elvis C., Bob M., Lou Reed and John Cale, Roxy Music, The T'in Heads, Cake, Iggy, Tool, 10 cc, CCR, Stones, Blues and my own music.

All of my friends (few) who need the macho-ness of Jimi or the Raunch of current "Pungent Pop" types are resistant to this thing of brilliance called XTC, but on a road trip-on those long Texas highways- in my car- on my CD player-they are going to get a dose of Quali-XTC.

Flexiblity. keep that in mind. Just accept these guys are goin' to do it. Might not be English Settlement or Skylarking. Just pop it in and let it send you.

Hardly ever hear mention of Human Alchemy, Miniature Sun, Another Satelite, Dying, Vanishing Girl, Pale and Precious, Blue Overall, Shake You Donkey Up, I Can't Own Her, That Wave, Rook................ the list of great songs go on.

I only wish I could jam with the guys, don't they need a new guitarist. (Andy's licks are right there dude)

Colin is an awesome bassist and am blown away with what these guys put together in the musical space of things. beats strums low voice high voice...

Jim

Name: d.j.
Subject: time for change
-- Aug 8, 2000 at 9:08PM
time for a change my ass. i've grown up w/ xtc. their the only thing that makes me feel young sometimes. i've made so many versions of greatest hits compilations that that anyone perusing my cd collection may become worried I may become a stalker. In a word: brilliant

Name: jill
Subject: oops
-- Aug 1, 2000 at 2:01AM
sorry if i offended anyone other than mizz lizzy.

Name: mizz lizzy
Subject: you know...
-- Jul 27, 2000 at 7:12PM
1.fuck off & die jill
2.brill article
3.d�you think colin looks a bit like Jonny Greenwood out of Radiohead?
Anyway even in his forties, he looks goood...
4.XTC rule 4ever :-)
XX 2 Chris,
Liz

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: maybe a dumb question, but.........
-- Jul 26, 2000 at 6:33AM
Jill/Donn,

I haven't ever heard that phrase before. I also had no idea Partridge was on The List. Very sorry I missed that, even if it was an ill-fitting forum.

And I must admit I too tried combining the two albums AV volumes--albeit just using the CD player's random function for the discs--and it was quite enjoyable.

Thanks for your comments

Name: jill
Subject: maybe a dumb question, but.........
-- Jul 26, 2000 at 1:30AM
I was wondering, has anyone ever heard the phrase ".....the grass is always greener when it bursts up through concrete" used before? I've been asking around & I haven't had any positive responses. Let me know if I'm alone in my wonderment.

Also, did anyone catch Partridge on 'The List'? I don't regularly watch that program, but I happened to catch his intro & of course, was interested. Call me an activist but I think the people at
VH1 should all be castrated for putting him on that show with a group of teenagers. No fair.
To Donn- "skylarking" is also one of my favorites. So much exploration was done on that album, they really came into themselves. As for combining both AV1 albums onto one tape.....I tend to think that each collection was meant to be heard in its own light, but, whatever gets you.........Jill

Name: Donn
Subject: XTC as Icons
-- Jul 23, 2000 at 4:51AM
Message from across the pond. (USA)
I have been into XTC since White Music. It is hard to compare one album to the next, but if forced I would claim "skylarking" as the definitive XTC album. There is such beauty and truth in that album.... of course then there is "english settlement"... and "oranges and lemons"..and... etc..

As for Apple Venus and Wasp Star. They confirm the genius of Partridge/Moulding. But... I think it works better when mixed...as I have done on tape. Alternate the songes from each CD.... or create your own songlist. One thing I do miss is the percussive excellence of songs like "Scarecrow People" or "Melt the Guns". These are small complaints.

One final note: These gentlemen are not rich?... that is a travesty... but one thing I do know... if it were not for there music.. this world would be much poorer!

Donn

Name: ALAN
Subject: XTC ('87-'00)
-- Jul 17, 2000 at 3:57PM
SHEER GENIUS ALWAYS SEEMS TO GO RELATIVELY UNHERALDED.AT LEAST IN THE PRESENT TENSE.
MAYBE THEIR BRILLIANCE WILL BE RECOGNIZED 50 OR 100 YEARS FROM NOW.MAYBE
HISTORY WILL EXPOSE THEM AS THE MOST IMPORTANT POP/ROCK BAND EVER,(INCLUDING THE BEATLES)DARE I SAY IT!
PROBABLY NOT,BUT IT MUST BE KNOWN (NOT JUST MY OPINION)THAT "ENGLISH SETTLEMENT","SKYLARKING","ORANGES&EMONS","NONSUCH","APPLE VENUS-1"AND "WASP STAR" ARE AMONG THE SMARTEST,MOST COMPLETE,ORIGINAL & GREATEST RECORDS EVER MADE!
THANKS.

Name: Lori
Subject: XTC
-- Jul 10, 2000 at 11:52PM
XTC rules. Can't wait to hear more of them. Listening to good ol' Mummer now and just marveling at their talent. Good to the last drop.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: AV1&2
-- Jun 26, 2000 at 4:02PM
Jill,

Amen, sister. Though it's some sick human need to want to rank things as good or bad, or somewhere along the spectrum--as you say, when dissecting such original musicians as Partridge & Moulding, we really must realize that they are a band that truly moves us.

Name: Jill
Subject: AV1&2
-- Jun 26, 2000 at 12:56AM
First, let me thank you for creating this little outlet, I have virtually no one to discuss this music properly with & I have thoroughly enjoyed reading everyone's comments. I was recently re-introduced to these musical/lyrical geniuses by a friend & have been obsessed ever since. My first listen to AV1 was religious. Easter Theatre is one of the most beautiful pieces of music I've ever heard & the rest of the CD is incredibly diverse in mood & content. AV2 took a couple of listens. But only because my limited mind was expecting it to elicit the same reactions from my soul. It definitely has a different feel altogether. But I've now embraced their differences & love it all the way from the gritty Wounded Horse to the happily trancsendental We're All Light. Personally, I cannot say enough good things about this band. They are true pioneers in what has become the plastic-y, polished, regurgitating business of music. It is my wish, however, that music fans of any description would refrain from comparing one album to another (myself included). Everyone has their favorite tunes due to whatever life has offered them. It seems counter-productive to me. I mean, let's face it, true artists, ie Colin & Andy, will continue to create in whichever direction they're headed. We can listen or not. & I think it's pretty safe to say that anyone corresponding here is on the same ride. Let's enjoy it.

Name: Poppy
Subject: Question to Stevo
-- Jun 20, 2000 at 8:34PM
Just curious as to what you mean by XTC keeping people instead of letting them go. Bloody hell, Partsy and Moulders have been together for over 20 years! That in itself is amazing. Yeah, Dave Gregory is a great musician; yes, he was an important part of XTC. But, let's face it, Colin and Andy are the heart and soul of this band, and this girl, at least, hopes that they carry on and continue to fill our lives with their amazing pop tunes. I don't care what anyone says: WASP STAR IS GREAT!!
That said, glad they're still one of your favourites!

Name: An LS.n Reader
Subject: Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC
-- Jun 16, 2000 at 1:00AM
When I heard about the new record I thought Hurra! I bought it and thought Aaaa. then I got volume 2 and am a mite disappointed, but there are some good pickins. On the pop side there are a few repetitions from the previous(or stylistic hooks> Ok!)
Xtc should keep people instead of letting them go. XTC; STILL one of my favorites! Stevo92037@prodigy.net

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Wasp Star!!
-- May 31, 2000 at 6:22AM
Poppy,

I couldn't agree more. The album is certainly worth getting excited about. It seems like many of us die-hard fans spend a good amount of time thinking--this song is so amazing, how come they're not the biggest band in the world? Like you said, though, there is a lot of questionable taste out there. Let the public have their boy bands and matchbox 20. We've got one of the best kept secrets around.

Thanks.

Name: Poppy
Subject: Wasp Star!!
-- May 30, 2000 at 9:14AM
Oh, I'm a happy girl! I've been an XTC fan for a looooong time, and it's always cause for celebration when a new album comes out. It never ceases to amaze me how brilliant they are. Thanks, Chris, for this great site! I heard a touch of some other XTC albums in Wasp Star,too--definitely a bit of "English Settlement" once or twice. Not to say that anything about this album is redundant or re-hashed, mind you! Quite the contrary.
Brilliant, indeed, as I, too, had hoped. They truly shine brightly yet again on Wasp Star.
Every now and then I wonder why these guys aren't millionaires, then I remind myself your average schmuck on the street has his music appreciation skills in his arse.
For those of you intend to listen to Wasp Star with your ears and the white matter in between them, enjoy!!

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: wasp star
-- May 28, 2000 at 4:53PM
Adam/Steve,

I must say Wasp Star is as brilliant as I had hoped. Even better than I had hoped in many ways.

"Stupidly Happy" & "Wheel & The Maypole" are by far my favorites. The single greatest moment on the album is when the guitar kicks in (after the word "guitar," of course) on "Stupidly Happy."

I also completely love the Police-y "You And The Clouds Will Still Be Beautiful," the Paul Simon-y "We're All Light," the Matt Johnson-y "Wounded Horse," and the countless other tracks that sound ripped from some of XTC's greatest albums--"English Settlement" and "Oranges & Lemons."

I'm just so happy how amazing this album is.

Name: adam.
Subject: wasp star
-- May 25, 2000 at 1:32PM
just listen 2 wasp. cuts 2-3 are the best.back quote do what you will but harm none.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Dear God!
-- May 23, 2000 at 6:37AM
Steve,

Oh, I intend to have a happy May 23rd alright! I'm extremely excited to get Wasp Star today. From the very little I've heard of the album already--it sounds exactly like what I've been waiting for. I'll let you know my opinion (as if the world is waiting to hear what I have to say).

Thanks for the heads-up, as always.

Name: Steve St .Thomas
Subject: Dear God!
-- May 20, 2000 at 11:10AM
Chris!! Have you heard any of this thing called Wasp Star yet? Call me "virginal", cos' I don't get into "Give me the early demos now! Give me 'Boarded Up'recorded in Colin's loo in 1994!" I do love getting hold of these demos when they are available - but I really enjoy waiting for the final versions. Chris - this album is f***ing awesome. I sit here in London amazed that "Standing In For Joe", and "Stupidly Happy" aren't already being played on the radio (But I haven't really listened to radio since 1991 - but the lads where I work have BBC Radio One on all day- AAAAARRRRRRRGGGGGGHH HHH)
"Standing In For Joe" is such a great song, one of the best songs Colin has written - and it's so damn catchy..... I also really really really like "The Wheel and the Maypole" - even though on first listen I realised it had gone into a country jambouree, which is not my taste, but then I learned to relax and just enjoy it!!! Anyway, I'm hoping the Limited Edition "I'm the Man Who..." gets released somewhere over here as it appears to be only released through TVT, and not Cooking Vinyl (but I have to check that out) Have a happy May 23rd .... Steve

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: JUST LIKE A MAN DOG I'M CHASING MY TAIL IN A CIRCLE!MMMMMMM?
-- May 19, 2000 at 7:45PM
Frank,

You must be as excited as I am for this Tuesday--May 23, when Apple Venus Vol. II (Wasp Star) hits the record stores.

Thanks for your comments.

Name: Frank Austin
Subject: JUST LIKE A MAN DOG I'M CHASING MY TAIL IN A CIRCLE!MMMMMMM?
-- May 19, 2000 at 1:35PM
I WOLULD LIKE TO SAY WHAT A WONDERFULL EXPERIENCE I'M HAVING LISTENING TO NONSVCH WHILE I DRIFT INTO SLEEP EACH NIGHT. I REALLY LIKE HUMBLE DAISY AND OMNIBUS FOR IT'S RICH TEXTURE AND AUDIO DESIGN.AS AN MUSICIAN MYSELF IN LOS ANGELES,IT'S A WONDER HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE NEVER HEARD OF NONSUCH.ANYWAY I'LL PROBABLY USE ALBUMS LIKE NONSUCH, SKYLARK, APPLE VENUS VOL.I TO CALM MY NERVES EACH NIGHT UNTILL...ZZZZZZZ

Name: Andy Munro
Subject: XTC VINYL FOR SALE!
-- Apr 18, 2000 at 4:34PM
I have some XTC records for sale at cheap prices.
E-Mail me in London at
andy@munrec.screaming.net
and ask for my XTC List.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: WaspStar FruitBat
-- Apr 14, 2000 at 6:40AM
Steven,

Hey, I've written many articles for LeisureSuit! But none have generated the response of this one.

I'm glad you agree about the videos. I too had only seen "Senses." MTV did also play "Dear God" occasionally, and "The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead" once or twice.

I bought a bootleg tape of many of the videos you indicate, several years ago, and I think you're right on the money. "All of a Sudden" is pretty uneventful, and "Generals & Majors" is just extremely cheesy. I kind of liked "Ball & Chain," but really none of them measure up to the songs.

Oh well. Volume II is slated for a May 23 release here in the U.S., and so I'm a happy boy.

Thanks for responding (and setting the record straight).

Name: Steven St.Thomas
Subject: WaspStar FruitBat
-- Apr 12, 2000 at 12:48PM
WOW! People are still writing to you about this article. I find this absolutely amazing!
Sorry it took me awhile to respond, but we're all busy aren't we? Have you written any new articles yet, or are you just living off the glory of this one 1999 article???? As I was saying in the last post - a friend of mine gave me a video of XTC - Live in Holland 1980. You know, of the people on stage, Andy is always the one who looks the most into it! Strange - as he's the one that stopped it all from happening!!! I had never really listened to the guitar part he plays on "Love At First Sight", kinda just listened to the song as a whole, but seeing him play it is another thing entirely. It's all over the place!!! And oddly funky in places too...
I also see that you still get the odd one or two messages misinterpreting this article still! Sorry to see that. But I agree with you on a number of points - especially the videos. If anyone has seen the XTC videos from 1978 to 1983, they do the band no favours whatsoever. The videos from "Mummer" are an improvement though, especially "Human Alchemy" and "Funk Pop a Roll", but if you see videos from BLACK SEA or DRUMS AND WIRES - man they are Godawful! "Generals and Majors" is just plain rank, and it's a shame because the song is so good. The videos from "English Settlement" are a little better, but you can tell that Virgin didn't really care about investing anything in XTC, and it shows in their videos. The only video I ever saw from XTC when I lived in America, and MTV first came out, was "Senses Working Overtime" and that was it! MTV never bothered playing "Ball and Chain" or "All of a Sudden", but after seeing these videos, I didn't miss much other than getting more interested in XTC at an earlier stage. I really didn't pick up on how good they are until "ORANGES AND LEMONS" came out.
So to those who misunderstand Mr.Tyrrell's article, please read through the whole thing, it may be the only article he's ever written (ha ha)but it's a good one with some very valid points made.
Steve - UK

Name: mic cooper
Subject: xtc
-- Apr 6, 2000 at 9:37AM
yes it is an unfortunate thing but MY BIRD PERFORMS wont earn enough for us. sorry for my ignorance, does andy suffer the same fate as brian wilson

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: xtc
-- Apr 4, 2000 at 6:59PM
Mic,

Sadly I would guess there's more money (and more gigs) in playing a cover of "And Your Bird Can Sing" than "My Bird Performs." But you should give it a shot anyway!

Name: mic cooper
Subject: xtc
-- Apr 4, 2000 at 8:32AM
at the moment I play in a Beatles cover band . but what i really want to do is play in a XTC cover band

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: A Testimonial Diner
-- Mar 19, 2000 at 9:43PM
Zan,

I was one of the three people who actually saw Paul Simon's "The Capeman" during its short stint on Brodway, and can attest to the talent of Mr. Blades.

However, I gotta go with the boys from Swindon's original version as the better of the two. In fact, for my money, I would say that only They Might Be Giants were able to improve on the XTC version on the cover album. But that's just me.

Anyway, I prefer sacrilege over no opinion at all.

Thanks.

Name: Zan
Subject: A Testimonial Diner
-- Mar 19, 2000 at 9:02PM
Is anyone else in awe of Ruben Blades treatment of "The Man Who Sailed Around His Soul"? The man was seemingly born to play this. I daresay his version may exceed our own beloved XTC in pure listenability. Sacrilege yes, but to my ear true.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Response
-- Mar 6, 2000 at 10:32AM
Jill,

Did you read beyond the first parargraph? You didn't, did you? If you're not completely illiterate or ignorant you might not jump to such hasty notions of ridiculousness.

What was said in the first paragraph? Three band members left? No commercial success? Their company has dicked them over? Oh, and their videos suck. These are all facts, except the latter--which is true nonetheless.

Now read the rest of the goddamn article, please.

The Fucking Moron

Name: Jill
Subject: Response
-- Mar 5, 2000 at 7:18PM
you are a fucking moron with no ear no taste and no place to speak if you can possibly stand behind any of the first paragraph you printed . Don't waste time trying to write , critique , or do anything that required thought , because you're only wasting time .

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: AV2
-- Feb 29, 2000 at 9:39PM
The Mole,

Thank you for the info! Very exciting news. I hadn't heard a thing about Volume II since early last year, and I had no idea that they were actually going to be releasing it soon.

I wait--as I'm sure all the people listed on this page do--with eager anticipation.

Thanks again.

Name: The Mole
Subject: AV2
-- Feb 29, 2000 at 11:15AM
Chris,
AV2 will be released in Japan on March 15th and on April 3rd for the Rest of the World.
It has been called a return to the Guitar Driven sound of Black Sea by Andy himself. I have heard the demo's which sounded very un rockish to me but hopefully the lads can still crank out a few rockers.
XTC is also slated to take part in the new Paul McCartney tribute lp. They will be contributing their version of Uncle AlbertAdmiral Halsey.
A cd made entirely from Demo material and titled "Fuzzy Warbles" is also planned and work has been in progress on it for more than a year. It has been reported to contain as many as 8 CDs of demo's.

Look for them all at an Independant Record Store near you and help support good music.

Cheers

The Mole

Name: brian
Subject: swindon vacation
-- Feb 26, 2000 at 10:15AM
In 94' my wife and I honeymooned in London, rented a car and sidetripped to Swindon.With careful detective work I found the Partridge's home( a modest flat) with no one home. A woman walking past said Andy's wife (I
don't remember her name)
was collecting her children at school. We asked to meet them, Mrs Partrige complied and she was unbelievably gracious considering they were to be divorced
in two weeks time, afact we learned from her. She
told us Andy would write a song complaining of what a bitch she was.It seems she was right.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: AV 1
-- Feb 20, 2000 at 10:38AM
Rick,

Thanks for the comments. Have you heard any word on when/if there will be more to Apple Venus? The natives (me) are getting restless!

Name: Rick
Subject: AV 1
-- Feb 19, 2000 at 10:01PM
On the contrary, I fell madley for AV upon first listening. I didn't stop playing it for several weeks, by then knowing all the words/chords. I have to hand this one to Colin; my 2 fav songs are his "Frivilous" & "Fruit Nut". Colins' songs are always like the prize in the box of Cracker-Jack, and I've never been disappointed. Even "Too Many Cooks.." still gets me pogo-ing 'round the room today, as fresh as ever.
More please.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: anything
-- Feb 18, 2000 at 6:46AM
Abe,

I hear what you're saying. But once--just once--I would like the lay-public to get it too. It would be so nice to hear XTC appreciated for all the shit they've put up with over the years. In the end, though, they are appreciated by the likes of us, so I guess it doesn't really matter.

Name: abe
Subject: anything
-- Feb 17, 2000 at 7:11PM
XTC is far more brilliant than any band will be/ become. In a land of making money or making the road downwards, XTC never lost themselves. In addition, they wrote some of the best songs ever written.
I hope their new album comes out soon, and i hope the lay-public hates it. cause i'm gonna love it!
peace

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: ANYTHING
-- Feb 16, 2000 at 6:41AM
FAN 2,

You're welcome.

Name: FAN 2
Subject: ANYTHING
-- Feb 16, 2000 at 1:37AM
Thank you for many wonderful years of XTC. From early years to present I have enjoyed about every song made, and I cant say that for every band I have followed or waisted good money on.
Keep the music imagination.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: return?
-- Feb 15, 2000 at 9:40PM
Steve,

I did have a good new year--and thanks for asking.

"Love at First Sight" is from "Black Sea," yes? I think my favorite on that one has always been "Living Through Another Cuba." But "Love" is definitely a terrific one.

Do you still feel that you'd be OK if there wasn't an AV Volume II? I bet you're anxiously awaiting that one now, like the rest of us. But I understand your point that AV I is a brilliant album on its own.

Thanks again.

Name: steve st.thomas
Subject: return?
-- Feb 12, 2000 at 1:18PM
Chris,

Glad to see you're still at it. Recently been watching XTC Live In Holland 1980, which has renewed my appreciation for "Love At First Sight"
Hope you had a good new year. Steve / London, UK

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: person
-- Feb 11, 2000 at 9:54PM
Shenpha,

At least my keyboard has the letter "e" on it.

Rtard.

Name: shenpha
Subject: person
-- Feb 11, 2000 at 2:46PM
your websit bits

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: xtc
-- Feb 6, 2000 at 2:03PM
John,

What a great way of putting it--songs that seem to have already happened in your head. It is just such a gut level connection that makes XTC so special for so many of us.

Thank you for responding.

Name: John
Subject: xtc
-- Feb 6, 2000 at 10:01AM
there has never been a band that so deeply moved me emotionally as xtc has - during the early years of drums and wires and the anticipation of new songs and stories I have always been - attached to this band - the songs are things that seemt to have already happened in my head - and then this band ... well it works for me!! As a person who has been on the edge and off and now back ( I am a certified drug counselor that works with terminal aids patients - inpatient and have seen over 376 deaths) I emphasize with andy and his desire to just BE. keep being!peace
john

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: av1 av2 xtc etc
-- Jan 30, 2000 at 10:21AM
Matt,

Thank you for both comments.

This second point is what I now find so striking. I have been lucky enough to see firsthand the kind of response XTC generates--and it is indeed overwhelming.

Growing up, I thought I was the only one who "got" them. I'm sure many of us felt that way. But instead of feeling no longer special, I've felt such a part of this terrific community. Reading responses such as yours has meant the world to me, and I truly hope Andy, Colin (and the others) know how beloved they are.

Name: matt hickman
Subject: av1 av2 xtc etc
-- Jan 29, 2000 at 4:27PM
i think one more thing that we should mention about xtc is the pure love that the fans have for the band, theyre like some mystery that were all competing to explore and find, and were all so freaking intelligent, listen to us, there is no sign of prepubescense(spelling?) among any of us, except for my spelling of course. but honestly av1 was very mature ,but you have to expect that coming from to men who have been making songs for over 20 years, theyre refined and theyve never sold out, never sitting down to think, hmm now, what would those kidd like to her today, no no no, they write and ask us to take it or leave it and for those who take it, we cant , chances are we cant get enough!!!!!!!

Name: matt hickman
Subject: xtc
-- Jan 29, 2000 at 4:15PM
i love em, and i love the article, i wish theyd tour, but i understand the situation, i know the can keep the cds coming and i cant wait for every minute of it.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: AV1
-- Jan 25, 2000 at 7:36PM
Angela,

Thanks for hopping this way. Ironically enough I was humming "Green Man" today too, and I haven't even listened to the CD in a couple months. It's about time I did.

I'm still waiting with baited breath for AV2. I'm beginning to think it's not coming out at the end of 1999. Call it a hunch. If anyone hears anything, let me know.

And thanks for your two cents. Looking at their unfortunate track record, that's probably just about the sum that Andy & Colin saw from your purchase of the album!

Name: Angela D
Subject: AV1
-- Jan 25, 2000 at 11:04AM
I was just hopping around the net and stumbled across this page. To add my 2 cents, I love AV1. XTC has never put out a bad album IMHO... and I've been humming the Green Man ever since the first time I heard it.

XTC is the most underappreciated band out there. I was so psyched to get my grubby hands on this CD ~ FINALLY. I am surprised that some didn't like AV1. I thought it was up to their usual standard of excellence.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: See the "Big Picture"
-- Dec 27, 1999 at 6:34AM
Donald,

Well put!

Although in a strictly trivial way, it is fun to see what fans pick as their likes/dislikes. XTC is indeed our common ground, and I doubt that any who take the time to respond to this article would disagree that--whether they like a song or no--the band is an integral part of their life.

Thanks.

Name: Donald J. Turner
Subject: See the "Big Picture"
-- Dec 26, 1999 at 2:11PM
I continue to see a lot of opinions concerning the choice of songs or the albums that people
don't like or think should have had fewer songs. My point is, that if you see the Big Picture, from Andy's point of view, then you see that if Andy had compromised his convictions so that he could "Sell-out" and become just another music industry "Hack" or Slave, then I believe that the reason behind some of the past albums is not so much his choice, but the dictates of the producer or the record company not wanting song "X" or "Y"
on this album. If you see this underlying dichotomy from past interviews, then you might appreciate the body of work that XTC has put forth as a whole and not just a critique of "your" personal likes
or dislikes. I too, have
my favorites, but to be unfair to Andy for writting sappy love songs, is tanamount to
complaining about other people's children when you've never had any yourself. One last ranting before I get off my soapbox, "Hold me my daddy" is a song that even though I don't have
close ties with my father for personal reasons, it's a song that for me, elicits some strong emotion because I know that even though I've tried to be
myself, it's still not good enough for him, this I feel in a nutshell
is similar to the predicament that Andy has faced with regards to the music business, he's had to remain true to himself, even though it meant giving up on "easy" paydays to pursue his "way" of making & giving us, his fans, the best music he's capable of giving us, so if you don't like
this or that album or song, fine...but remember
there doesn't always have to be a specific purpose for this or that song getting on an album, but the choice is yours to appreciate the song, or complain about it, personally, I'd rather appreciate a song than let everyone know how fickle a fan I am by saying "oh I'm a fan, But except for this song". I know that Andy is a reasonable person, so for me, I can't see an atheist like Andy making any decision that isn't rooted in common sense or pure logic. That's "My" opinion of XTC, from an unconditional fan.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: xtc is timeless
-- Dec 23, 1999 at 10:00AM
Gary,

I too have gone back through the old XTC stuff, and found that they indeed have a much longer, and more important shelf life than anything you can find in stores today. Twenty years from now we most likely will still be referring back to "White Music" and the like.

That's of course if the Y2K bug doesn't wipe out humanity in a week.

Thank you for sharing.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: XTC's appeal
-- Dec 23, 1999 at 9:54AM
I like them because they rock.

Thank you for the very poetic comments.

Name: kevin caldwell
Subject: XTC's appeal
-- Dec 23, 1999 at 4:46AM
Intelligence has always
had a limited appeal, in
terms of numbers of
people attracted, at any
given moment. XTC is the
ultimate in intelligent
bands. What on earth was
anyone expecting from
their career? It was
written in stone from the
beginning (for XTC) that
there would be all of
these weird ups and downs
in their career, following
the normal development of
a normal human with normal
emotions.

It should also come as no
surprise that XTC has
evoked such very powerful
feelings inside of human
beings. XTC is, after
all, the ultimate human
being sort of band.

They seemed "new wave" for
a time; it's still a good
thing, even now. But it
was after that trendy new
wave period that they
really flowered. Their
first four albums were
unusually high-caliber
"new wave" music. But
they exemplified a normal
pattern of growth, and a
lot of very uptight people
hard a hard time forgiving
them. I cannot fathom such
people. We are the better
for having witnessed their
example. Maybe we would
all like to try and make
our own art. Maybe we
would like to try and feel
that which every fan
allegedly feels for his/her
idol. Maybe we'd like to
actually go and have a life.

We are better for having
observed the process.

Perhaps we all will
continue to feel that
growth, powered on by
the beating of hearts.

Name: gary choronzy
Subject: xtc is timeless
-- Dec 21, 1999 at 8:22AM
I just started giving a re-listen to my XTC collection, and realized that I wasn't thrown back into the 80's new wave state of mind that happens when I break out other music from that time (like the Cars, for example). These tunes still hold their own today, much like Elvis Costello & Squeeze, but I could be arguably wrong. All I know is that I feel like I've re-deiscovered some truly fantastic music in XTC, which is great for me, cinsidering the last few trips to the music stores have been disappointing as far as new music/bands are concerned.

BTW, Primus covered "Scissor Man" on their "Rhinoplasty" release, and it really shows the genius of Andy Partridge, w2hich I guess is where this whole re-discovery began.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: XTC Back Catalogue
-- Dec 17, 1999 at 7:45PM
Robin,

Thank you for your comments. I never tire of hearing from the (surprising to me) large number of XTC fans.

I must admit, you were a fan long before me--as I was only five when you first heard Nigel. In the late '80s, circa Skylarking and Oranges & Lemons, I got pretty obsessed with the band, and worked my way back (thankfully in CD format).

That's how I know that all the albums, from White Music on, including the Dukes' Chips From the Chocolate..., and Explode Together, and many other rarities are indeed in print. If you're looking for rarer stuff, you'll probably have more luck on-line, on something like e-bay, or a service where CD suppliers will special order the goods.

I'm sorry I'm not more help. Perhaps others will have more specific ideas. Something tells me it's all out there somewhere, although you may have to ransack Andy's house to find some.

Until Apple Venus II...

Thanks,
Chris

Name: Robin
Subject: XTC Back Catalogue
-- Dec 17, 1999 at 11:50AM
To fill a few idle moments I conducted a small experiment to see if there was any news re the Swindon songsmiths and joy of joys there is, and it's here on your site. Well, comments from fans and a brief history of the band, which doesn't actually consitute news but welcome reading anyway.

I have been a fan of XTC since 1979 when I first heard 'Making plans for Nigel' and was hooked immediately. Since then I have bought all their albums, and even before listening to then just know I shall love them.

The problem, however, is this, I was a DJ back in the 80's so all the albums and singles I bought were vinyl. Not a problem in itself, but it meant that I never bought CD. Now that I have grown up and discarded my 'Dave Doubledecks' I buy everything on CD and would like to acquire the XTC back catalogue in this format. As most of you have been saying, the fan base is mainly hardcore and I think it is a result of this that most record stores do not stock a vast amount of XTC music. This creates the problem of where to buy the old albums. Do any of you have any ideas?

Incidentally, when reading the various articles on XTC to be found on the web it becomes clear that XTC have not exactly wallowed in financial success - so, if your albums are vinyl why not do the same as me and upgrade to CD, better sound reproduction for your sensitive ears and additional income for our favourite band! Perhaps that way we will hear Apple Venus II that bit earlier.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Apples and Lemons
-- Dec 12, 1999 at 9:47PM
Thisispop,

If they were never punk, then what do you call that noise that they put on? Just kidding--I wanted to use a line from your titular song. Cheap little joke.

Whatever one may brand XTC, and thankfully most don't even try, it is a credit to their breadth of work and talent that they have released so very many brilliant pieces of art over the years. In fact, I would disagree with almost all of your choices for their best works (and yet, I'd take any of them over the songs of 99% of the bands out there). But XTC's layers upon layers of musical invention over three decades--coming up on four--thankfully provide us each with our own distinct set of favorites.

Thank you for your comments. And let me know if you hear anything about A.V.II, as I too am frothing at the mouth.

The Author of Simpleton

Name: thisispop
Subject: Apples and Lemons
-- Dec 12, 1999 at 3:45AM
Dear Chris,

Just came across your article, and must admit I was a little dumbfounded by some of the comments that other XTC fans have made about Apple Venus Volume One.

AV#1 is a work of genius. Frivolous Tonight, Harvest Festival, The Last Balloon and Your Dictionary are some of the finest songs that Andy and Colin have ever written. If some of your readers are unwilling to let the lads progress and evolve then maybe they should shove their copies of White Music and Guillotine up their arses and slink away wimpering into a corner that will forever be labelled 1978.

Apple Venus is a masterpiece. Equally as good, if not better, than half of their output to date and a record that pisses all over the likes of Nonsuch and, dare I say it, Black Sea - the most overrated XTC album ever.

I would, however, take umbridge with the 'XTC were punks..' comments that keep popping up. XTC were NEVER a punk band, as anyone who calls themselves a fan knows. They were lucky enough to hitch a ride (and a record deal) on the coat-tails of the UK New Wave scene, but they were never a punk band - not in the '76 UK sense of the word or the mid-'60's US sense.

We, as fans, should not be knocking our favourite band, but encouraging them. There is nothing wrong with constructive critisism, but some of the comments made on your page are just pathetic. It was well worth the seven year wait, although I hope to God that AV#2 arrives soon!

Incedentally - favourite album The Big Express or Apple Venus Volume One...fave track Train Running Low On Soul Coal, Funk Pop A Roll, Harvest Festival, Heatwave, Living In A Haunted Heart, Frivolous Tonight, Dying, This Is Pop (Single Version).....

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: favorite xtc xtc
-- Nov 24, 1999 at 9:10AM
Kate,

What a great story! The real questions now are:

a) Did you name your son Nigel or Graham? If the latter, did you make him promise he's be a good boy?!

b) What does your son think of "English Settlement"? I know when my mom was pregnant with me she ate a lot of cheese, and now that's my favorite food item. It would be great to know that "English Settlement" had a similar effect!

Thank you so much for your letter. I completely agree with the comfort level of the album. And it's so timeless (not too many early '80s albums sound light years ahead of the stuff we hear today)

I also echo your frustration at the lack of XTC's exposure. When I turn on the radio today I hear nothing but the same 5 horrible songs practically looped on every station. It gets my blood boiling when I then listen to XTC, and know that so many people will never hear such original music.

But it makes me feel good to know that you're doing your part to convert the rest of the world!

Anyway, it relieves me to know that I'm not the only one out there who thinks XTC is a brilliant band (confirmed by many of the terrific responses to my article) and that "English Settlement" is truly their masterpiece (thanks to you for that)

Chris

Name: kate morgan
Subject: favorite xtc xtc
-- Nov 23, 1999 at 5:37PM
in regards to your response dated 8/13/99 1316 I concur wholeheartedly with your recommendation to people that they purchase English Settlement. It's my favorite and has been for over 15 years. I call it my "comfort music"-I can be in the worst mood possible and all I have to do is hear "no Thugs in our house" or "yacht Dance" and everythings allright! In fact, it got me thru labor with my son 12 years ago. Perhaps no other artists with the exception of Yes and Robyn Hitchcock do that for me. Ialways play xtc for my friends and without fail can find someone to agree with me that this is music better than that on the radio. Occasionally I run into someone who has heard of them but most of the people i meet never heard ofthem-a situation which is a source of both delight and frustration. I genuinely enjoy getting into stuff away from the mainstream-the frustrating thing is that this isthe stuff which really should be mainstream! I get more than a little tired of the pap they foist on an unsuspecting public! How nice that we can have access to music from a band which doesnt mind wearing their intellect on their sleeves! Up Uffington!(i made a real nice linoleum block print of the Uffington Horse on the English Settlement cover--maybe someday I'll make a pilgrimage to Swindon and some of the archaeological sites there. Does Andy give guided tours? ha ha! km

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: red curtain
-- Oct 25, 1999 at 4:01AM
Ian Onions,

Thanks for setting us straight. Now is that Red Onions or Green Onions. The latter, of course, is scallions.

Name: ian onions
Subject: red curtain
-- Oct 24, 1999 at 5:02PM
Hello to all you colonials! It really is terribly sweet to read about how passionate you people get over englands finest ignored band. I've been a fan since "White Music" came out (I sold my copy of "Queen II" to raise the cash" and have almost everything that they recorded.I even got to see them on their final tour, in Doncaster.I think they only ever performed live about 3 or 4 times after that.
Anyway, your correspondent who queried "Green Curtain" Actually, it's "red curtain",the composer credit on the back of "Chips from the Chocolate Fireball" C.D.It applies to the tracks "What in the world?", "Vanishing Girl","Shiny Cage" & "The Affiliated", and is the Nom de Plume of Colin.
Hope this clears things up,
Toodle- Pip
Ian Onions

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Thanks, and stuff to poke fun at
-- Oct 11, 1999 at 10:03PM
Scott Howe,

Once again, your response was truly diabolical.

I can't make fun of you because:

1) You described your fawning e-mail as "schoolgirlish"-- a word I'm all too familiar with when reading my own writings of praise.

2) You took the time to give props to Colin, which is classy.

3) You INVITE me to make fun of you. Now if I took you up on that, I'd be a real asshole.

So thanks for being a jerk and ruining my fun.

Name: Scott Howe
Subject: Thanks, and stuff to poke fun at
-- Oct 10, 1999 at 8:51PM
Thank you for responding to my schoolgirlish e-mail. You are correct when you say those of us who have seen the light that emanates from Them that art from Swindon are a wee bit passionate about them (hence my frequent liturgical tonality when I speak of them. I don't even know why I do that...)I just wanted to add that in my ferverntness I did not give Colin his due and so I guess we will call him The Gos and Andy the God of the tree that springs forth what is herefore known as XTC. Now I feel I have given you plenty to make fun of at this point so I will shut up now...

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Everything
-- Oct 10, 1999 at 7:55PM
Scott,

You're right on both accounts. He is God and Gos. (I hate when people realize their own mistakes--what am I supposed to make fun of?!)

Your comments were great. I feel so lame responding to all of the XTC yaks, because they all seem so passionate and well thought out (with the occasional typo--Yes!) Anyway, I second your emotions, and thank you for sharing.

Chris

Name: Scott Howe
Subject: Gos vs. God
-- Oct 10, 1999 at 2:57PM
I just wanted to clarify that I meant Andy Partridge is GOD not Gos, though the more I think about it, what's the difference?

Name: Scott Howe
Subject: Everything
-- Oct 10, 1999 at 2:50PM
I'm really astounded to see so many diverging opinions about XTC. I guess it just proves my theory that Andy Partridge IS Gos, or at least divinely schizophrenic...I read somewhere by some classical composer that if a piece of his was accepted and liked at the first performance, he knew he had failed. Point being, if you don't like certain things XTC have done, it probably means those are the best ones. Listen again! There is not a single song this band has done that hasn't got at least a nugget of sheer genius in it. And as far as thier relative obscurity goes, point proven again. Most people just can't see beyond thier own eyeshells...

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: A.V., what else?
-- Oct 3, 1999 at 5:29PM
The Green Curtain,

Wasn't that one of the Dukes' aliases, or was it some other color? Sounds familiar.

"I Can't Own Her" is great. I'm still puzzled why "Easter Theatre" was the single released. Not a bad song, but I could think of several more accessible ones. Ah, well.

Thanks for the comments, TGC.

Name: The Green Curtain
Subject: A.V., what else?
-- Oct 1, 1999 at 11:06PM
Love this page! I just wanted to add that "I Can't Own Her' off of A.V. is my personal fave. The other writers don't seem to have noticed it. Brilliant orchestration, lyrics, etc.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Good for the soul
-- Sep 25, 1999 at 4:19PM
GD,

Thank you so much for sharing your story. I think you really hit a nerve with all XTC fans out there.

To be honest, I used to think of myself as one of the only people on this earth who really cared about the band. This was not only naive and narcisstic, but grossly incorrect. All of the responses have shown me what a shared experience XTC really is, and how we are all that much luckier for having them in our lives.

Thanks,
Chris

Name: Greg DeCori
Subject: Good for the soul
-- Sep 25, 1999 at 5:33AM
Good for the soul... that's my post near death realization tonight.

I took notice of XTC in 1984 as a junior in high school and have been on board ever since. Every release is eagerly awaited and there never seem to be enough, especially the past seven years.

People seem to be put out with different stages of XTC's library. Each volume has it's own merits and lends itself to a progression in the band's maturity. As the band has matured, some of the albums take several listens to truly appreciate. It's like a new pair of jeans... it takes a time to appreciate them.

The point here being... these boys (especially Andy) have bared their souls to us for a long time. In doing so, a certain kindred relationship has developed for me and most of you reading this.

This realization is more vivid to me tonight than ever before. Returning home this evening from a week long sales trip, another vehicle almost took me out on an Apache reservation in rural Arizona. Several hours, two Sierra Nevada Pale Ales, one Apple and Venus later and everything seems ok again.

When all is said and done, XTC does something musically that's difficult to categorize. They hit a nerve that no other band does, and it feels like a worn pair of jeans or a soul mate.

Be thankful we've got them.

gd

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Re:Apples & Lemons
-- Aug 13, 1999 at 8:29PM
Steve,

Damn! I wish I had included all that in my article. What a great summary of XTC's evolution. Kudos.

I don't want to slight you with a brief response, but I think you've made a lot of good points, and singled out my personal favorite XTC albums, so there's not much more I can do but agree.

I will say this, as an addendum to your sociological observations--which, again, I agree with--this article has surely generated a lot of responses. I may be stating the obvious, but XTC really hits a nerve.

After each even-slightly-critical posting about the band, it seems fans were lightning quick to respond. Yet I felt very defensive too, because I would never try to put them down. They're my XTC--seemingly a sentiment shared by many readers.

It's just really interesting how this little band from Swindon, who most of the world doesn't know exists, has been enshrined in the minds of its fans for three decades, in ways most commercially successful bands will unfortunately (for them) never know.

It may be music on a farmboy's wages, but the love felt by XTC fans is truly staggering and delightful.

Thank you very much for your comments.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Favorite XTC
-- Aug 13, 1999 at 8:10PM
Quinn,

I do listen to a lot of pop music--some of it, irritatingly poppy--so are tastes are most likely different. However, I must agree with all your song choices on "Nonesuch," as well as your analysis of XTC's greatest assets.

I know I've responded to a lot of responses here with an urging for people to buy "English Settlement," but I'll do it again, since you may not have that one. I think it's a magnificently cohesive, melodic, work of genius. It took me a couple listens 'til I realized it was the one I always kept coming back to.

In my book, there aren't really any bad choices in their discography (save for the experimental instrumental collection "Explode Together," which sounds like Michael Winslow (from the "Police Academy" movies) attempting to recreate an hour's worth of noise). Some of their early stuff is a little rough around the edges, though I find that I still enjoy listening to them.

"Drums and Wires" and "Black Sea" are particularly good also.

Anyway, thank you again for your excellent input.

Name: Quinn
Subject: Favorite XTC
-- Aug 13, 1999 at 4:16PM
Since you asked...
I first have to admit that I haven't heard all of their releases. I need to go back and get some of their earlier work. I agree that Nonesuch is a little too long, but it has some of my favorite tunes, such as "The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead,"My Bird Performs" (I love the way it seems to comment on "And Your Bird Can Sing"), "The Smartest Monkeys," "Crockodile" (probably my fave on the CD because I love the tune, the texturing, Andy's singing and the whole angst of it), "Dear Madame Barnum," and "Wardance" (I love that oboe sound). I guess I don't really have a favorite CD as much as a large collection of favorite songs. My musical tastes are pretty eclectic, but I don't listen to a lot of "Pop" music. Pretty much just XTC and the Beatles. The things I love most about XTC are the things I hate about lesser bands: the immaculate production, powerful hooks, and overall
ear-candy that their music offers. Of course, I also get off on the wild creativity that their most brilliant tracks knock me over the head with. I guess it's precisely that combination of sweetness and innovation that I love about Apple Venus, Vol. 1. Thanks for asking!

Name: steve st.thomas
Subject: Re:Apples & Lemons
-- Aug 13, 1999 at 3:15PM
I�ll try to make this short and sweet, but probably won't. After reading your article �Apples & Lemons� I couldn�t help but get irritated. Unfortunately, it was with the people commenting on the article, rather than the article itself. I find it hard to take �personal opinion�, and all that it implies seriously, when it comes across as narrow minded and resistant to change. But alas, some people just can�t go with the changes.

I believe �Apple Venus � Volume One� to be one of the best albums released by XTC. I would be happy not even knowing there was a Volume II to be released! But I also agree with others that �Nonsuch� is not one of their better works, and I would add neither is �Go2� or �Mummer�. But there are reasons I believe make these albums hard to get used to in the context of XTC�s work.

As everyone should notice, these three albums close significant chapters in XTC�s life. And the albums that have followed these individual works reveal an even stronger band, with better ideas, and more resilience to conformity. �Drums and Wires�, �Black Sea�, and �English Settlement�. I don�t really need to illustrate my point, but it�s easily seen that each album here is an improvement on its predecessor � lyrically, musically, conceptually, etc. Band stops touring, loses drummer, out comes �Mummer�. No wonder it was hard to grasp for Virgin, let alone Terry Chambers. We see touches of what has been ("Funk Pop A Roll�, �Gold�, �Me and the Wind�), what could be (�Love On a Farmboy�s Wages�, �Jump�, �Desert Island�) and what was to come (�Human Alchemy�, �In Loving Memory of a Name�, �Great Fire�). �Human Alchemy� fits very easily onto �Big Express� as �Funk Pop a Roll� fits onto �Black Sea�.

�Big Express�, �Skylarking�, �Oranges and Lemons�. I think we see a pattern here? Individuals may prefer �Skylarking� over �O & L�, but I still see this as each one outdoing it�s predecessor. Not only that, but look at the sales generated to prove the point further. I think that�s how �Nonsuch� qualifies as a chapter closer for this period in the XTC books. It sums up their years with Virgin, (and unknowingly Dave Gregory) in 17 songs. It also sheds light on what is to be. If �Rook�, �Wrapped in Grey�, and �Bungalow� didn�t give fans some warning of what was to be, then I can�t quite believe there disenchantment with �Apple Venus�. You knew it was coming!!!!

I think it�s so interesting to see XTC do this whether consciously or unconsciously, and it makes �Apple Venus � Volume One� such a pleasurable experience. YES, it took a couple of listens to get used to, but once you realise how beautifully put together the album is, you realise XTC is now on the upswing again. Each album is going to continually get better until another upheaval or change occurs.

Hopefully, we won�t see Andy or Colin leave it all together, but I feel the next few years with XTC will be eye/ear/heart � opening. Those that don�t want to be part of it are entitled to their choice, but I really think they�ll be missing out on something that constantly improves. XTC have proved that before at least three times now (by my count), and that �Apple Venus � Volume One� is only part of a piece!
It doesn�t even count as a whole album really. Only part of the jigsaw I suppose.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Apple Venus
-- Aug 12, 1999 at 10:21PM
I wish I had a definite date on Vol. 2. I asked Colin about it, and he made it sound like the release would depend on them getting the money to complete it. Which, as I'm sure you know, is the most unfortunate side to XTC. I think it's a crime that they've never seen their profits over the decades, and just obscene that they have all these songs ready to go, but we'll have to wait 'til the cash is there for them. Colin did seem optimistic about the fall.

He also mentioned that Bravo was doing a special on them, but he didn't have many of the details on that either. I'm anxiously awaiting that as well.

Your questions:

1) Nonesuch--I think there are just a few too many songs on the damn thing. I feel like I'd listen to it more if there were about 13-15 on it, making it a little tighter.

I also felt that the verses to a couple of the songs were just incredibly annoying, even though I'd love the choruses. Holly Up on Poppy and Bungalow come to mind. And Crocodile used to rub me completely the wrong way, but now it's one of my favorites.

It's hard. I started with Oranges & Lemons, and Skylarking, worked my way back, and Nonesuch was the last (before A.V.), and--possibly unfairly-- the least-listened to in my XTC collection.

2) I wish I could say I interviewed them both, but I want to make it clear that I only spoke with Colin. I met Andy later that week at a CD-signing in Boston, and he seemed very reserved, but quite congenial. I told him Colin spoke very poorly of him, and Partridge laughed. That was all I could have asked for, really.

As far as Colin goes, it was a tremendous thrill. I used to interview a lot of celebrities, much bigger names than Moulding, a couple years ago, but I specifically sought this opportunity out because I knew it would be the chance of a lifetime. And it really was.

He was extremely down-to-earth, brutally honest (he didn't at all seem like he was trying to sell me the album), and talked about a great number of things other than XTC. We spoke of They Might Be Giants, and Burt Bacharach tunes, and just the kind of life he likes to lead.

He seemed completely at ease and genuine--no small feat since my mindset while asking him questions was probably that of a fawning schoolgirl.

It was an amazing experience, and I really appreciate the fact that you're so interested.

Now my question for you (though it may be trite and, again, fawning-schoolgirl-ish):

What's your favorite of their albums?

Name: Quinn
Subject: Apple Venus
-- Aug 12, 1999 at 1:21PM
Anyone heard what the tentative release date might be for Vol. 2? I've been searching the Web, but all I've been able to establish is that work on it continued in April and it should be out "sometime this year." I'd like to know with a little more specificity.

Also two questions for Chris:

1) What don't you like about Nonesuch? I don't mean to put you on the defensive, you are entirely welcome to your opinion, I'm just curious 8-).

2) Was meeting/talking to XTC as cool as it sounds? Does their avoidance of the limelight make them reluctant to correspond with journalists or do they seem relatively at ease about it?

Thanks!

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Apple Venus
-- Aug 12, 1999 at 1:18AM
Quinn,

Thank you for your comments. I definitely agree they deserve a hell of a lot more press, but I suppose they'd be a different band if they got it.

I would also say that River of Orchids, Knights, Greenman, and even Your Dictionary is among their finest work to date--which is certainly saying something.

And I too hope that Vol. 2 will be a nice, loud companion piece to Vol. 1.

Name: Quinn
Subject: Apple Venus
-- Aug 11, 1999 at 5:57PM
Okay, I'm coming to this late, but I wanted to thank Chris for writing about XTC. I'm just happy to see such a deserving band get some press and I think it is actually pretty obvious that Chris admires their work. I have to disagree with some of the opinions offered about Apple Venus. I think it may be their best work yet. River of Orchids is one of the most original songs I've ever heard. It is simply an entirely new kind of music. It's not loud guitars, but how ballsy of them to have opened their first lp in seven years with it! I'd Like That is your basic love song, but it's richly textured and pleasing to the ears. I don't find it any sappier than other great love songs in the literature of pop. Knights In Shining Karma could have been an outtake from Abbey Road and though you can hear the influences, I can't think of a higher compliment than that! Greenman is a unique and powerful song and breaks new ground. My only complaint is that Colin didn't contribute more songs to this release. Just wait until Vol. 2 and we'll probably get plenty of guitars and more songs from Colin. Pax.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: Owen Willingham is a complete moron
-- Aug 10, 1999 at 10:36PM
I should point out that I used the word "inteded," which is very close to the word "intended," but has a different, German meaning.

Thanks for the support, BenRad. Vomit on you, Owen.

Name: BenRad
Subject: Owen Willingham is a complete moron
-- Aug 10, 1999 at 5:15PM
I didn't realize they let idiots like you out onto the street. Retarded nimrods like yourself shouldn't even be allowed to comment on music (or music criticism for that matter). You "probaly" couldn't even get past the first paragraph due to your complete lack of sense and intelligence.
I bet you think that "Explode Together" is XTC's greatest work, you poo face. Or, maybe you've only heard "Dear God." Forget it, you're not even worth poo face, dirt face.

Name: Chris Tyrrell Responds
Subject: Re: apples and lemons
-- Aug 7, 1999 at 12:53PM
What is your problem? Do you feel the article was somehow derrogatory to XTC? I in no way inteded it to be.

I think you picked up on a lot of points made in the first paragraph. That they don't tour, that their videos are awful, that Dave left the band... Again, these are facts.

Try reading the last paragraph. Or the middle. I hope you will see that the point of the article is that XTC is a brilliant band--always has been-- and if some people don't "get it," then that's fine.

Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC by Chris Tyrrell

Andy Partridge and Colin Moulding

Colin Moulding

Andy Partridge

Apples and Lemons: an Interview with XTC
by Chris Tyrrell